Since Bitcoin (BTC) was birthed, an array of narratives have swirled around its mythology. While many say it is a replacement for PayPal, Visa, and similar incumbents, many have come to the conclusion that it is a digital store of value, or, as put by some, a digital gold.

Some have gone as far as to say that Bitcoin is easily better than gold in many departments, hence the “Drop Gold, Buy Bitcoin” advertisement campaign launched by an industry fund last week. However, some haven’t taken this narrative lightly.

Cryptocurrency and Gold

“Cryptocurrencies Are No Replacement For Gold”

For those who missed the memo, Grayscale, an investment services subsidiary of the New York-based Digital Currency Group, launched an extensive ad campaign that touted Bitcoin as “gold 2.0.” On Wednesday, the company released a 45-second advertisement that depicted two youngers physically “dropping gold” as those around them struggle with the heavy, cumbersome commodity, escaping to what is assumed to a society predicated on the use of digital assets.

Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies weren’t depicted in the video, but the point was made clear, BTC and potentially other cryptocurrencies may act as a proper alternative to the precious metal, which has held a hegemony as the go-to store of value for millennia. As Grayscale writes on its webpage accompanying the campaign and remarks in the video, “drop/bye gold, buy Bitcoin.”

Although many took this advertisement sitting down, some have taken up arms against the narrative being pushed. Legendary commodities trader and crypto chartist Peter Brandt, for instance, quipped that the “Bitcoin versus gold” dialogue is “nonsensical and asinine,” noting that the two assets have inherently different narratives and valuation models, despite what some see as overlapping characteristics.

Some have simply stated that cryptocurrencies are not a viable replacement for gold. In a recent blog post published by the World Gold Council in the wake of Grayscale’s commercial, researcher Adam Perlaky noted that gold’s market is less volatile and more liquid. Indeed, volatility levels and order book spreads in Bitcoin markets are dramatically higher than that of gold. But as a number of industry thinkers have pointed out, such volatility and liquidity will likely be only temporary, as any nascent asset class or newfangled investment opportunity is inherently subject to the shortcomings of undeveloped markets.

Perlaky didn’t stop there though. He adds that unlike gold, Bitcoin remains unregulated and non-tantalizing, touching on the fact that the cryptocurrency exists in a regulatory grey zone and that most common consumers aren’t actively seeking out BTC allocations. And as so-called “gold bug” Peter Schiff, the chief executive of Euro Pacific Capital, adds, “you can’t mine Bitcoin without using gold,” touching on the metal’s unique viability in electronics and modern innovations.

Does The Bitcoin > Gold Argument Have Merit?

However, some are adamant that it is only a matter of time before Bitcoin surmounts gold.

In a recent research paper, Grayscale (obviously a tad bias) does note that Bitcoin, in many respects, is drastically better than its physical counterpart. BTC is mathematically scarce, capped at 21 million units; BTC is decentralized and verifiable through the Internet; BTC is portable and divisible through the UTXO blockchain system, and is unconfiscatable. Gold, on the other hand, has an effectively unlimited supply, risks around its centralization (earlier this year, over $1 billion worth of Venezuelan gold was locked), an inability to be easily divided and transported across borders, and concerns around its purity.

The benefits that Bitcoin provides over gold have led some, like Gemini’s Tyler Winklevoss, to quip that the only thing that gold has over BTC is a “3,000-year headstart.” But whether or not the cryptocurrency will be able to catch up remains to be seen.


Buy Crypto    Trade Crypto
eToro Risk Warning: 66% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

Avatar

Posted by Nick Chong

Nick has been enamored with cryptocurrencies since finding out about them in 2013. He now reports on crypto- and blockchain-related news for a number of leading outlets.


All content on Blockonomi.com is provided solely for informational purposes, and is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any security, product, service or investment. The opinions expressed in this Site do not constitute investment advice and independent financial advice should be sought where appropriate.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *