TLDR:
- The Kalshi hearing is set for Monday at 11:30 a.m. Eastern before Justice Melissa Crane. She will consider James’ request for a temporary order.
- Kalshi says “within or from New York” could reach its nationwide operations because the exchange is headquartered in the state. James’ office disputes that reading.
- A federal judge denied the CFTC’s renewed emergency request on Friday. She found the agency had not shown likely success on its preemption argument. New York’s case proceeds.
- Federal appeals courts have split over state authority in event-contract cases. Three circuits have sided with states and one with Kalshi. A Supreme Court appeal remains possible.
The Kalshi hearing is scheduled for Monday in Manhattan state court. New York Attorney General Letitia James is seeking a temporary restraining order against the event-contract exchange. Kalshi says the proposed wording could force it to close nationwide because its headquarters are in New York.
James’ office says a nationwide shutdown is not the state’s goal. Federal judges have declined, for now, to keep the enforcement case in federal court or block it. The state judge will consider whether Kalshi must change its operations while the lawsuit proceeds. The request concerns contracts tied to sports, culture, elections, and other events.
The Kalshi Hearing Centers on the Scope of the New York Order
Justice Melissa Crane will hear James’ request at 11:30 a.m. Eastern Monday. Her order would bar Kalshi’s unlicensed gambling operation “within or from New York,” and service to state residents. It covers sports, culture, elections, and other event contracts. It would also block users under 21 and ads on college campuses. Crane has not ruled.
Kalshi says “from New York” could carry the order beyond state borders. Since it is headquartered there, the company argues limits on New York operations could affect every customer. It warns the order could force open positions to be liquidated. Kalshi says that conflicts with an August Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) order to keep it operating. Crane must assess the wording and its potential reach. The CFTC order directs Kalshi to continue its exchange functions.
James’ office disputes Kalshi’s reading. A Friday filing says the requested order would leave lawful futures and swaps available. The state urged Crane to disregard the CFTC’s August directive. It cited a November ruling that criticized the agency’s intervention in a separate prediction-market case. The parties describe conflicting consequences from the language.
The Kalshi Hearing Reflects a Wider Fight over Market Oversight
The Kalshi hearing follows two federal decisions that shifted the case’s route. On Thursday, U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick sent James’ enforcement case back to state court. Kalshi argued the lawsuit belonged in federal court.
On Friday, U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield denied the CFTC’s renewed request to stop New York’s case. She found the agency had not shown likely success on its federal preemption argument. Reuters reported that three appeals courts have sided with states, while one has backed Kalshi.
The CFTC says the Commodity Exchange Act gives it exclusive authority over event contracts on federally registered exchanges. The agency and Justice Department sued New York in April, arguing state restrictions cannot govern those markets. The CFTC’s preliminary-injunction request remains pending. It also says James’ case could shut down a federally regulated exchange. New York declined to pause enforcement, leaving Crane’s request active beside the federal lawsuit.
The dispute extends beyond New York. Appeals courts have split over whether states can apply gambling rules to Kalshi’s sports contracts. The Fourth, Sixth, and Ninth Circuits ruled for states; the Third Circuit sided with Kalshi. The Fourth Circuit ruled against Kalshi in Maryland this week, but its majority gave different reasons. Judge Roger Gregory said federal law does not preempt Maryland’s gambling laws, even if the contracts are swaps. Judge Stephanie Thacker concluded the contracts are not swaps and amount to sports betting.
That split could lead to further appeals and Supreme Court review. Gaming attorney Daniel Wallach wrote that a broad order could prompt an emergency appeal. That remains a possible step, not one announced by Kalshi or the court. The Kalshi hearing will address James’ request for temporary relief and the reach of any order. The jurisdictional dispute remains active in federal litigation. The CFTC’s injunction request against New York remains undecided.





