Tesla (TSLA) Stock Slides 12% YTD as Analyst Warns on Robotaxi Timeline

Key Takeaways

Table of Contents

Andrew Boone from Citizens launched Tesla coverage with a Hold rating and no set price target, pointing to distant profitability from robotaxis and humanoid robots
Shares began Thursday trading at $394.11, reflecting a roughly 12% decline year to date within a 52-week span of $293.55–$498.83
The automaker anticipates no substantial robotaxi revenue before 2027
Just 40% of Wall Street analysts recommend buying Tesla shares, significantly under the 55–60% Buy rating norm for S&P 500 companies; consensus target price stands at $408.52
Institutional shareholders control 66.2% of Tesla’s equity, while company insiders have offloaded more than $12.3 million in shares over the last quarter

Tesla (TSLA) shares kicked off Thursday’s session at $394.11 following Citizens analyst Andrew Boone’s debut coverage featuring a Hold recommendation without a specific price objective.

Tesla, Inc., TSLA

Boone’s cautious stance revolves primarily around timelines. While he acknowledges “immense” upside in Tesla’s physical AI initiatives — including autonomous taxi fleets and humanoid robotics — he believes substantial earnings from these ventures remain too distant to warrant a bullish position currently.

Tesla debuted its autonomous taxi service in Austin during June 2025. The program has since grown into several additional markets, yet company leadership doesn’t anticipate significant robotaxi-generated revenue until 2027 or later.

Boone also highlighted concerns that a gradual expansion could ultimately disappoint shareholders who have already baked considerable optimism into current valuations.

Tesla shares climbed 0.4% during premarket hours to $395.77 before regular trading commenced. Heading into Thursday’s session, the stock had declined approximately 12% since January, though it remains up roughly 33% over the trailing twelve months.

The Hold recommendation hasn’t substantially impacted trading momentum. Tesla had already retreated about 6% across the previous two sessions entering Thursday, leaving the stock essentially unchanged for the week.

Analyst Community Remains Divided

Boone’s conservative outlook mirrors broader Wall Street uncertainty. Approximately 40% of analysts tracking Tesla currently recommend buying shares — markedly below the 55–60% Buy-rating benchmark typical for S&P 500 constituents.

Among the 45 analysts monitored by MarketBeat, 21 maintain Buy ratings, 20 hold neutral positions, and four recommend selling. The average price target across all analysts sits at $408.52.

Recent rating adjustments have varied considerably. RBC lifted its target to $500 alongside an Outperform designation. Mizuho reduced its objective from $540 down to $480 while maintaining its Outperform view. Both Guggenheim and HSBC currently hold Neutral/Hold positions.

Tesla delivered Q1 earnings per share of $0.41, surpassing the $0.39 analyst consensus. However, revenue totaled $22.39 billion, falling short of the $22.96 billion forecast. Year-over-year revenue increased 15.8%.

Institutions Accumulate While Company Insiders Exit

Despite divided analyst opinions, institutional investors continue expanding their positions. Resona Asset Management increased its Tesla allocation by 1.8% during Q1, elevating its holdings to 892,972 shares valued at approximately $329 million. Tesla now represents Resona’s ninth-largest portfolio position.

Additional investment firms such as Crestwood Advisors, Calamos Wealth Management, and Private Capital Advisors similarly boosted their Tesla exposure. Institutional and hedge fund ownership currently comprises 66.2% of total shares outstanding.

Insider activity tells a contrasting story. Director Kathleen Wilson-Thompson divested 26,409 shares at $378.11 on April 30, trimming her position by 35.3%. CFO Vaibhav Taneja sold 3,000 shares at $450 on May 13 for tax withholding purposes. Combined insider dispositions over the past quarter total approximately $12.4 million.

Tesla’s 52-week trading range extends from $293.55 to $498.83. The stock’s 50-day moving average sits at $409.15, while its 200-day average rests at $409.76 — both positioned above current trading levels.

✨ Limited Time Offer